Find wedding rings you actually love: Insider advice that jewelry stores may not want you to know

Comments on Find wedding rings you actually love: Insider advice that jewelry stores may not want you to know

1. I HEARTILY second the last point. Make sure that it is a ring your intended wears on their ring finger, which may seem obvious but I own a lot of rings. Boy Blue took my engagement ring (which his mother generously provided from her own collection) and had it sized with a ring from my jewelry box — the ring that I wear on my thumb! Suddenly I had a gorgeous ring and I had to wait 72 agonizing hours to wear it because it was sized improperly!

   • Try eight weeks because its over chinese new year and it was too big to resize so it has to be remade. Ive been engaged two months and havent been able to wear my ring so I feel your pain!

   • Oh no! At least he tried, right? *smh*

   • I have a small ring from when I was a kid that today only fits my pinky finger. Apparently my guy took it into the store, told the jewelers which finger it fit, and they extrapolated the size for my engagement ring from that.

     It fit perfectly from day one.

   • (WARNING: European sizing)

     I have child-sized everything but my hips. The salesman gave FH a sizing clip to take it down a size or two just in case, but it was still at least a K.
     I’m a H or an I.
     The Ring is just silver and cubic zirconia (found out my correct size while shopping to humor FH as “it’s only a temporary one!” – and I’m writing this two years later). I still had to wait a few weeks to get it back.

     My most important factors while looking were setting height and price. Both because I’m a klutz and would scrape the bejaysis out of myself or someone else with a higher stone, and The Ring is covered in scuffs and dings which would incur a helluva lot more guilt if it were platinum or gold and precious stone.

     I’d love a band in steel or other hardwearing metal, or a non-polished finish. Unfortunately they don’t go down to my size with a reasonable price tag attached…

2. My sweetie proposed with an orange sapphire solitaire and I love it. I had no idea and I couldn’t have picked out a ring I liked better myself.

3. I have heard that due to the popularity of tungsten rings, many EMS are now carrying pliers/grips designed to shatter the ring. You lose your ring, but you keep your finger!

   • This is true about titanium rings, too! And some places have warranties where you can exchange broken rings for new ones if this happens to you.

     • Second this.
       My dad’s an aerospace machinist, so he basically cuts aircraft-grade titanium all day. He says most tools that will cut steel will also cut aircraft-grade titanium.

       I’ve read that in some cases, you may need to have the ring cut in two places so the ring can be removed rather than bent-and-removed (like they would for silver or gold). Dad confirms this, that titanium doesn’t bend as well as softer metals. But it does cut. It’s not like whatever Thor’s hammer is made out of. Your finger will be fine.

       After talking with my dad and an ER friend-of-a-friend, my husband and I ended up buying titanium rings with confidence. I erred on the side of caution and got basic-grade titanium, which is slightly softer than aircraft-grade. We’ll take them off when dealing with machinery (like fixing a car), but that’s general ring safety no matter the material.

       • My dad’s a stainless steel welder by trade. He wore his (gold) wedding ring for about a week until he heard about someone in a competitor’s factory who had lost an arm because their ring got caught in a machine. 30 years on, he’s still ringless and with all his fingers.

     • Yeah, my boyfriend’s father works at a family business in an auto shop (as does my boyfriend) and he’s had at least 2 tungsten steel rings made for him with an unbreakable guarantee at the place he got it. Funnily enough he managed to destroy both of them in his line of work – and I think the store would have kept replacing them for him if he hadn’t decided that it wasn’t worth it.

       Unbreakable doesn’t always mean unbreakable, but a good store will understand and have a policy like this.

       Having said this, there’s still no way I’d ask my boyfriend to wear a wedding ring when we get engaged/married. I don’t want to count on them being able to be broken – I’ve heard horror stories of things being caught in machines or whatnot and fingers/hands being lost in the process.

       It’s definitely something to consider.

   • The store I worked in was in a mill town. It always worried me when guys would talk about how their ring would get crushed if a log fell on their hand. heh

   • My brother in law is a firefighter/EMT. What he did is get a ceramic ring from a craft fair so it can just be smashed with anything to break it off his finger. Thought it was a pretty great solution to “I want to wear a ring” and “I want to keep my fingers”

4. This post makes shopping for a ring in person sound really good, but I’m looking for an ethical ring (I’m flexible as to metal and stone). Is it possible to combine both?

   • Totally possible, but of course that completely depends on your particular region. If you live in a town with only big-box jewelers, it might be harder… but I’m betting even they could direct you toward ethical choices. Vintage rings are also a more ethical option available even in smaller markets.

     • Vintage is a great way to go! And some of the chain stores have special lines of jewelry that are certified conflict free, etc. If you can’t find one in person, I would suggest still trying on lots of styles to figure out what ones you like, and what sizes and shapes look good so that you can then take that information to an online jeweler.

       • The other way to go is lab-created. My emerald/diamond ring is all geologically fake, but you would never know!

   • Actually, even some big box stores are ethical about their diamonds, I can’t speak for all, but Kay has a conflict free policy as seen here http://www.kay.com/ContentView?catalogId=10001&langId=-1&storeId=10101&cmsId=consumer-information. Also, if you’re worried, try a certified stone, those usually come with documentation that can be traced to the source including all the info about the diamond itself as well as who cut it and I believe where it came from.

     • Their gold statement is pretty good but their diamond one is basically a really long “we follow the Kimberley Process” statement and that’s absolutely no longer a guarantee of ethical diamond sourcing. The Kimberley Process’s definition for a conflict diamond specifically relates to diamonds that fund the civil side of a war. It does not cover the abominable conduct of the governments who run mines (specifically Zimbabwe). Also, it’s super easy for uncut diamonds from a conflict country to be certified as KP diamonds by being smuggled into a KP country and mixed in with the rough diamonds there.

       We just got engaged so I’ve been doing a thoroughly obnoxious amount of research.

   • Yep, but I agree with the other posters it can be hard, depending where you live.
     You can get fairtrade/fairmined gold now, but only some jewellers carry it. Recycled silver seems pretty easy to find, and if you have a ring that’s vintage/from family some places can melt it down and re-cast it. Not sure re: platinum/palladium/tungsten.
     Re: stones, lab made, or ethical ones, or vintage ones re-set… there’s lots of options.
     I got my ring made bespoke by a small UK-based jeweller who is near me.
     Plus, if you go with a small, ethical jeweller, you’re also supporting a small local business/craftsperson, rather than a huge chain.

5. My partner proposed by ducktaping a proposal sign to our baby…. No ring 🙂 and I had our wedding bands (simple rose gold bands) made while visiting Europe. Easy peasy (now I have all the time in the World to pick an engagement ring, or not – up to me 😉 ) but I like this article very much!!! Thank you!

   • DUCKTAPING A PROPOSAL SIGN TO OUR BABY

6. Thanks for posting. I had no idea you could haggle and that month timing mattered.

   My mom gave me her wedding ring and we’re going to re-set the diamonds and trade the gold band for one that is my style. Is there any specific etiquette for something like this? Any pitfalls? Would it be better to sell the gold and pay for the new band in cash?

   • My wedding band was made from my grandmother’s ring, by a local goldsmith who melted down the gold and re-set the diamond in a band design I’d selected. My impression is that it’s always cheaper to skip additional people/steps… look for a goldsmith who can work with the ring you’ve got to melt it down and and recraft the setting!

     • Ariel is right. Find someone who can just melt the gold down and restyle it, or who is willing to give you a trade in. You’re likely to get a better deal without a middle man.

7. My band was an heirloom piece, inherited from my grandmother, so I knew I wanted an engagement ring to match. I HIGHLY suggest going and trying rings on, especially if you want to match an existing piece. Things I never would have though about, like the rise of the setting vs my band, how they feel together, will never become apparent from looking online or in a magazine. We also had quotes made for custom pieces from a few stores. While the final ring was a bit of a surprise (I knew what the “finalists” were, so to speak), his actual proposal was a total surprise! To me, that was more meaningful than not knowing what the ring looked like before hand.

   • This is exactly what FH and I did. We went looking at rings together casually when we found ourselves in a mall or a shopping center. We were able to find several rings that we both were drooling over, and then he made the decision without me there and did a surprise proposal (on the mountain where we scattered my grandpa’s ashes so he could be there for it).
     I know what we had it narrowed down to, but it was ultimately still a surprise, and I think the extra time spent with my FH made me appreciate what he picked out in the long run!

   • Agreed! My now-fiance and I went to several stores (box stores and local jewelers) and I picked out anywhere from 1-3 at each place that I really liked the style of and that he liked as well. When he was ready to buy, he went in knowing what I liked, what size I was, how big or small worked (don’t want it drown out or weighing down), and what materials I preferred (I needed platinum due to skin allergies). It worked out for both of us because he got his surprise proposal and I got a ring I loved.

8. I definitely recommend trying on rings so you know what you like. I would have expected to go with a larger ring because I have long, if slender, hands. But in the end, the .5 carat solitaire ended up being perfect. Had I not tried on rings I would have thought I wanted a much larger stone.

   In the same vein, I always knew that I wanted a simple solitaire ring surrounded by a pretty wrap or guard, until I went in to try them on. I had a placeholder band, so there was no rush, but when I tried on most of the guards and wraps I felt like they were to involved for what I wanted. Thanks to trial and error, I was able to find what I liked before we spent any money on it.

   Even if you and your partner want a completely surprise proposal, I would recommend trying on rings on your own or with friends so that you (or they) can pass on information about what you like. I feel very fortunate that my partner had no interest in learning about rings just to buy one for me so I was in charge of picking mine out. However, if this isn’t the case, do your homework. Know what you actually like on your finger and pass that along so that you come away wearing something that you love.

9. About haggling…as a jeweller, I would like to suggest that this advice would apply best to a chain type jewellery store moreso than a mom-and-pop type place where the work is made in-house, and the employees do not work on commission.

   We need to make a fair living too, so trying to bargain might be hit or miss depending on how receptive the jeweller in question is. Some are totally cool with it, some are fine with you asking but will tell you no, some consider it to be a devaluation of their skills and might say no with a bit more…vigor.

   • Funny, I was going to say that haggling isn’t likely to work that well at a chain store! I know someone who works at a Zales, and they can usually bump the price down 10%, but that’s about all they can do without risking their job. It all goes into a chain-wide computer system, and it flags discounts more than a certain percent.

     So I guess ultimately, big business or small business, it’s going to depend on the place (and possibly also the country? I’m speaking from a US perspective). Either way, my advice would be to not be a jerk about it. Be upfront about your budget, and if something is lovely but not affordable for you at its current price, say so! Chances are, if the salesperson in question can make it affordable for you, they will try to do so. Don’t say, “Oh come on, I know you can do better than that!” They probably can’t.

   • Miranda – that’s definitely a good point. I think that there just has to be respect. There’s nothing wrong with asking if a better price is an option, but you have to be ready to accept that it isn’t. 🙂

10. Re the cutting off of rings – has anyone seen this video? There are a few variations around. My partner is a jeweller & has sent it on to a few of his jeweller friends. He hasn’t tried it yet, but is looking forward to the next time someone asks him to cut off a ring. http://www.survivallife.com/2013/08/26/sneaky-medical-trick-that-helps-remove-a-stuck-ring/

11. I knew my fiance was going to propose soonish, and he asked me to pick out a few rings I really liked for him to get an idea. In the end, he bought one from an online store, but it came with a CZ diamond. I’ve always wanted a colored stone, so once he got the ring in, he had me pick out my stone separately from a gem buying website. He gave me the shape and size, and I went from there. So, he picked out the band, which I LOVE, and I picked out the stone, and he had it set.

    My best advise is to definitely go try rings on! I thought I was a size 6, I don’t wear ring much, but it turns out I was a 4.5! I didn’t even believe the jewelry consultant when they told me that. My fiance had to have the ring sized down from a 6 when he ordered it, but because of the shape of the band, I actually needed a 3.5. So it was resized down again by a different jeweler, and everything’s fine now. My ring is very ornate, and because I went with a colored stone, a London blue topaz, the stone was fairly cheap. However, it’s big, and if I could magically wave a wand and make it smaller, I would, but unless we go to a jeweler, the setting is made for an 8.5 mm stone. So, go try on different sized stones as well, even if you’re like ‘there’s no way I can afford a huge stone’ we went with a non diamond not only because I like color, but because the price was so more in our budget. You’ll never know what you like if you don’t try it on!

12. I’m so glad that I convinced my now husband to take me to try on the ring he had selected prior to him buying it. He’d picked a really pretty setting that made my fingers look like giant sausages. The setting that I tried on and loved was about 1/10 the cost and is so much more flattering!

    My husband originally wanted a plain white gold band and ended up with yellow gold with sort of a beaten texture after going and trying on a few different things.

13. Definitely suggest trying them on. My actual ring was a surprise and it is truly perfect for me, but I’m so glad I tried them on first! I really thought I would have wanted a totally different style until I started seeing them on my non-elegant boyish hands. The halo style with a colored stone I loved in pictures looked ridiculous on me, like I was wearing my grandma’s costume jewelry and I was a five year old. But my ring is totally lovely and classic and elegant, but it had to be the right kind for my actual hand.

14. I think this is absolutely great advice. I was actually a coworker of Melissa. Here is some more advice from an experienced jewelry person that might not be what you would expect. Go to a pawn shop! Unless you have some superstition you can’t get over, you’ll find that shopping at a pawn shop you don’t ever pay the retail price, just simply the weight of gold and stone. My engagement ring would have cost my husband over $2500 at a jewelry store. He paid $1000! He did it this way. He sent me to a pawn shop to “look at tools”. He knows anywhere there is jewelry I am going to look. He made sure my kids went with me and while I was looking at the jewelry he had them pay close attention to what I said I liked. 3 months later he proposed to me with the ring I had picked out! Going to a pawn shop isn’t exactly traditional but it will save you money in the long run. And when he saves money on your ring, he has that much more to spend on you in other things! 🙂

    • YES! Pawn shops FTW! My ring is an antique, and we paid a quarter of what it is actually worth at a pawn shop because they don’t care about age, setting, or stone…just what they paid out in gold value. If you’re worried about a used ring somehow being bad luck, as some people are, it isn’t an option you’d probably be comfortable with. But if you’re sentimental and obsessed with old things like I am (and CHEAP like I am) it might be your best bet.

15. This post is great! As a current jewelry store sales associate I can attest to many of these points! However a word of caution, many of the big name jewelry stores such as Jared the Galleria or Kay’s won’t be able to bring the prices down any further than what is on the tag. What you see IS our lowest price unless there is somehow a price change once we put the product number into the computer system. Obviously I can’t speak for all major jewelry stores but I work at Jared’s and I can tell you it’s exceedingly frustrating for both ourselves and our guest if they try and haggle the price down. Just be aware when you are purchasing your rings!

    • It really does depend on the store. I worked for a regional chain that had about 30 stores at the time (I’ll respect them and not name names), and their philosophy was to start at the top and then haggle down if need be. There were a few stores in our mall, and they all did the same thing. Obviously not every store will work this way. I think it’s ok to ask as long as you aren’t a jerk about it.

16. I have to add that my participation on other wedding boards has shown me that sometimes, taking your SO ring shopping without already having a proposal will drive some people CRAZY trying to figure out when and how you’re going to propose

17. My husband proposed without a ring, and we talked later about whether we wanted to do rings at all. When I decided I did, I went ring-pricing on my own in the jewelry district of our large city. I knew exactly what I wanted, and that I did not want a diamond. I checked out a lot of stores, and the main thing I learned is this: Having a custom-made ring can actually be cheaper than ready-made. After looking in the big flashy stores with a big stock, I went around the corner and noticed a tiny place with some samples in the window — a few engagement rings, but mostly gold religious metals and other jewelry. I figured that maybe a place like this would be cheaper, and went in to find out that because this man made everything himself, and didn’t keep a big stock, he didn’t have a big overhead — he didn’t have thousands of dollars tied up in his display case, and there was no middle-man. I explained what I wanted, and together we looked through catalogs. When my fiance and I went back to order it, he special ordered the gemstone and had the ring made in 3 weeks. It was quite reasonable.

    When we went back for wedding rings to match, he sketched one out for me that would fit together nicely with the engagement ring, and it turned out beautifully. For someone who started out thinking she didn’t want a ring at all, I love mine!

    • Allie, may I ask what the gemstone was and a ballpark figure on how much you paid?

      I also want to go this route and 3 weeks does sound pretty reasonable. But engagement rings can be SO expensive so I’m afraid of what you might be referring to as a ‘reasonable price’. 🙂

    • Totally this! I went to an independent jeweller who does bespoke work, and as I was having it made I got to say ‘I kindof like this style, would like fairtrade gold, our budget is x…’ then they designed me a ring I love that was within our budget. Plus, it’s unique. 🙂

18. I’ve been looking for just the right claddagh or claddagh wedding set for months. The jewelry stores don’t have what we want, and I was about to give up hope. I found just what we were looking for on Gemvara. Thank you so much for the push in the right direction!

19. Fantastic tips! Thank you for the great article.

20. Thanks for the information that which you have been shared. One my friend’s wife is going to celebrate her birthday at next month. He wants to gift a diamond ring to her. But he don’t know much about the diamonds. So can you please suggest best design at affordable price.

21. I love all things different but I want a wedding ring to go with my engagement ring but can’t find anything that goes well with it. My man bought me it for me in Lindos Rhodes last year and I love it but seriously struggling to find something to go with the unusual shape of it 🙁

22. I wish articles like this would deal with the fact of asking your significant other if they have metal allergies. That was something that I never read about and when I realized that I couldn’t wear mine, I felt so bad and didn’t have a lot of resources to go to. We ended up having to buy a completely new ring and I’m still looking for a wedding band that I can wear.

23. My FH took me ring shopping, but ultimately COMPLETELY surprised me when he proposed to me with a picnic on the beach. It was beautitful and perfect. The ring is absolutely gorgeous, I love it. I love it so much that I decided I don’t want to wear a wedding band with it. I’ll have a plain silver wedding band for on the day when we exchange rings, but after the wedding I’ll wear it on my right hand ring finger. Instead of another ring on my left hand, I’m having a heart-shaped subdermal implant implanted on my finger. All because I love my engagement ring too much to make any changes to it. Haha!

24. It’s also good to scope out certain times of year, if possible. In my family, we receive a ring on our 18th birthday. Mine was marked down by around 60%, because I’m born around Valentines Day.

25. My husband and I went ring shopping together before we got engaged. I narrowed it down to three, and he could tell which one was obvioisly my favorite, so he got me that one. I always recommend this route to people simply because I get so many compliments on my ring, and a disturbing amount of them are along the lines of, “wow your ring is so beautiful! I HATE mine.” This is always really awkward for me, but really, if you’re with someone and going to propose, it’s worth it to take a look together and avoid this. I feel like in most cases the method and time of proposal is a surprise, but that it’s going to happen at some point usually isn’t.

26. as someone from the industry I have to leave a thanks for the tips, I always try my best to inform clients about the materials and be as least tricky as I can – others do it differently and really scam off clients by selling junk and price it up 1200% – which not even will last long – or isn’t cleanable because the gemstone got treated a certain way makes it very easy to get damaged etc. there are so many tricks.

    may i leave a advice for everyone ? work with a goldsmith, don’t buy from the line – goldsmiths ALL have a codex of honor if it comes to jewelry selling – we are no jewelers we are creators and love to inform and we all hate if clients get mislead

Comments are closed.