bear grooms cake topper on offbeat bride

Unique gay and lesbian cake toppers

At a Glance

Unhappy truth: It’s hard to find an abundance of gay-friendly and/or gender neutral wedding stuff. From advice, to porn, to products our gender-bending, same-sex loving friends constantly get the shaft. We got a request for advice on where to find same-sex cake toppers, so I thought I’d show you some of the ones I’ve found over the years.

gay cake topper options
Look at all these customizable lesbian cake topper options from Custom Laser Studio

Unhappy truth: It’s hard to find an abundance of gay-friendly and/or gender-neutral wedding stuff. Our gender-bending, same-sex-loving friends constantly get the shaft. Recently, we got a request for advice on where to find same-sex cake toppers, so I thought I’d show you some of the ones I’ve found over the years…

51e865+KmtL. SS500Weddingstar is an interesting company. They’re the ones that brought us some of the most barf-tastic and insulting cake toppers, but they’re also one of only companies that make a bride-in-a-suit topper and sell their mini-people in separates, like this bride, and the more casual groom in grey.

gay cake toppers
Gay unicorn cake toppers on Etsy. Photo by Wild About You Photography
Lesbian Wedding Cake Topper
Lesbian cake topper from Etsy seller Custom Laser Studio

How much do we love that this cake topper has two brides in suits? And then there’s this one, with two high-fiving brides:

high fiving lesbian cake topper

 

And then of course there’s this “Finally Mr & Mr” gay cake topper.
finally mr and mr cake topper

But maybe you don’t want that laser-cut vibe. Maybe you want cute little sculptures. BEHOLD!

nerdy gay caketoppet
Adorably nerdy gay cake toppers from World Cake Topper

 

gay dinosaur cake toppers
When you also really love dinosaurs…. GAY DINOSAURS!

 

 

bear grooms cake topper on offbeat bride
STAAAAHP. How cute are these little bear grooms?

Does anyone else out there have advice on where to find good gay and lesbian cake toppers? If so, leave ’em in the comments.

35 responses to “Unique gay and lesbian cake toppers”

  1. Sarah Avatar
    Sarah

    I love all the animal s&p shakers/cake toppers. I’m a sucker for adorable animals, what can I say? Besides “Who’s a widdle CUDDLE WUDDLE FACE?!” that is.

    And dude, guys, way to pamper us with 4 updates in a day. Careful, or we’ll get used to this. 😉

    1. mary ruppenthal Avatar

      love these! also check out http://www.gayketoppers.com for the discriminating cake topper for those who do not discriminate…. a universal caketopper designed and hand-crafted by a lesbian architect in pasadena, ca. the specular aluminum rings are packaged in a glass jar with a tea candle to allow transformation from cake topper or sculptural object into a tea light lantern (tea light included) – see website for transformation into lantern.

  2. Cassie Sue Avatar
    Cassie Sue

    I’ve seen LOTS of cute animal wedding toppers on etsy. I was thinking of getting those mainly because I hate how cheesy a lot of bride/groom wedding toppers are.

  3. fichterleen Avatar
    fichterleen

    hah, we actually considered the last of your suggestions for our fairy springfest wedding :DD because honestly, if it’s hard trying to find lesbian cake toppers, it’s nearly impossible to find lesbian FAIRY cake toppers. i love that “sisters by heart” one though. a lot.

    we might just opt out of cake toppers completely, or make them ourselves.
    i had a brief moment of wanting to use my highly adorable miniature my little pony figures.. until my fiancées look popped my bubble of excitement 🙁 she’s right, of course… but they would’ve rocked that cake.

    1. Ann Avatar
      Ann

      My Little Ponies rock! I would love to see a cake with pony toppers!

  4. Nelle Avatar

    We’ve been planning for ages to put our favorite rubber ducks on the cake (we’ve got a small collection). His is a black, devil pirate one, while mine is a little white one wearing a hat and scarf. Eerily enough, they sort of look like us!

    http://www.squeakyducks.com/store/bigpirate.html

    http://www.squeakyducks.com/store/christmasducks.html

  5. Kayla Avatar
    Kayla

    We’re using Simpsons figurines — we’re a straight couple, but goddamn I hate those standard cheesy as a toastie cake toppers. And I’m a nerd.

    1. leelajuice Avatar
      leelajuice

      We’re using Han and Leia action figures as our cake toppers! Action figure cake toppers ftw!

  6. Aurora Avatar

    If you were doing cupcakes and into diy, I would suggest going to a toy store/model building store. They should have various models in various scales (army guys, people to hang out on model train landscapes, etc) that can be painted however you want. Gender neutral, maybe not so much. Customizable for race and sexual orientation? Totally.

  7. Erin Avatar
    Erin

    Awesome suggestions 🙂

  8. Topes Avatar
    Topes

    ..Actually my parents got me and my sister the sisters one when we were younger as a gift as a symbol of family unity.

    but okay. haha

  9. Rachel Avatar
    Rachel

    Melabo on etsy will make them for you.

    http://www.etsy.com/shop/melabo?page=1

    Though the last male ones she did seemed to be standing a bit far from each other, so I’d suggest asking if they could be closer:

    http://www.etsy.com/transaction/40680393

    She can take the heads from certain molds and put them on other bodies, so an easy mix and match! As for interracial, they’re all the same color though once in a while she paints them.

  10. J Avatar
    J

    A guy-guy wedding I went to actually used toy soldiers as cake toppers. It was pretty cute.

    1. Erin Avatar
      Erin

      Great finds, Rizubunny!

  11. ASP Avatar
    ASP

    Do you what else is hard to find? Gay-friendly wedding cards. If you are in Iowa City (where gay marriage is LEGAL woot woot!) go to http://www.rsvp-asap.com/.

  12. aaa Avatar
    aaa

    this post is awesome.

  13. Megan Avatar

    That fairy figurine is beautiful! And you are soooooooo right about the initial thing being annoying, as not all couple take the same last name. I am, but it’s only because I despise my biological father and can’t wait to get rid of his name once and for all.

  14. susan Avatar
    susan

    my mom actually got my fiancee & i that willow tree ‘sisters at heart’ figurine for christmas (she adorably did the whole ‘i know you two arent sisters,..but i thought the two girls holding hands fit’ cuteness)! i hadn’t thought to use that as our cake topper…i think it would work perfectly and would be a sentimental touch!

  15. Jen Avatar
    Jen

    My nephew bought us smurfette brides. Pretty cool for a 13 year old.

    1. Offbeat Intern Avatar
      Offbeat Intern

      ZOMG! Smurfette? Best idea EVAR!!!

      – Becca

  16. Casey Avatar
    Casey

    So I am not at all affiliated with this store, I was looking for a cute valentines gift that my honeyy would like and I discovered some interesting same-sex couple cake topper. They are “more traditional” complete with a gazebos. Not everyone’s style, but hey it is another option. Here is the link for the two grooms
    http://www.mcphee.com/shop/products/Two-Grooms-Cake-Topper.html and here is the one for two brides http://www.mcphee.com/shop/products/Two-Brides-Cake-Topper.html

  17. jenny Avatar

    We customized some little cute dolls I found in a store for my friend’s cake topper, they loved it:
    http://www.flickr.com/photos/philandsean/4027743354/in/faves-jennywenny/

  18. Ebelyn Avatar
    Ebelyn

    I realize my comment is a little delayed at this point, but these cake toppers are great for same sex weddings:
    http://www.etsy.com/listing/79655111/same-sex-cake-toppers-day-of-the-dead

    http://www.etsy.com/listing/79818821/same-sex-day-of-the-dead-cake-topper

  19. Tanya Bennett Avatar
    Tanya Bennett

    My girlfiend and I used the Died and Groomed mini living dead dolls. Whilest not two females it fitted in with our black and red themed and was such a different idea gender didnt facture in.

  20. Justin Avatar
    Justin

    Fiance and I are looking for something specific. Have seen and fallen in love with cake toppers that are 2 rings. Sadly, they are all for straight couples and one of the rings always comes with a “diamond” on top. Would totally be up for just ripping the “diamond” off, but I think that would probably leave an awkward mark. Anyone seen toppers of just two plain silver/titanium/platinum looking bands?

  21. Casey Avatar
    Casey

    Saw this website with a really varied collection of Gay and Lesbian friendly cake toppers, some I have not seen before and some I have. Hope this is a helpful resource!
    http://www.weddingcollectibles.com/Gay-Cake-Toppers.html

  22. Sammycakes Avatar
    Sammycakes

    I work at a photo lab and recently developed a customer’s photos… He and his husband used two stuffed teddies dressed as grooms. It was adorable, and totally fitting because they were bears ;D love it!

  23. Floofy Avatar
    Floofy

    I want to see a bride caketopper in a black tux for once, real smooth and classy like James Bond. *drool*

  24. Firen Avatar
    Firen

    I’m trying to track down the perfect Alice and Mad Hatter for my soon-to-be wifey and I. I don’t want the Disney version. I would be fine with the Tim Burton style, but I would prefer something styled after the original illustration. Any ideas?

  25. Jellifer Avatar
    Jellifer

    Wouldn’t it be a better idea to get those paintable figurines of anime & sci-fi characters. Not sure what they’re generically called, but I find them on most geek dedicated sites. Also, how about asking a friend for a tiny figurines sculpted in clay or play-doh- that could be thier wedding gift to you or if you can do it, great!

Find Your Vendor Team

Our Offbeat Wed Vendor Collective features wedding professionals identifying as neurodivergent, BIPOC, disabled, and more. Explore wedding pros who get you.